About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Greysheet Marketplace: Shield Nickels (1866–1883)

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

CAC
1883 5c Shield MS

Auction Ends: 7/28/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
5
1868 5c MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS66
16
1873 5c Open 3 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS65
10
CAC
1872 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS64
7
CAC
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-305 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS64
9
eBay
eBay
Sponsored
CAC
1867 5c Rays MS

Auction Ends: 8/17/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS63
6
CAC
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-301 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS63
10
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-304 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS63
8
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-303 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS63
8
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-302 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC AU58
9
1879 5c MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS AU58
12
US Coins and Jewelry
US Coins and Jewelry
Sponsored
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-304 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS AU58
9
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-301 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
ANACS XF45
9
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-302 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS XF45
14
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-302 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS XF40
8
1883/2 5c Shield, Overdate, FS-304 MS

Auction Ends: 7/27/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
ANACS XF40
9
1