About the Greysheet Marketplace

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Greysheet Marketplace: Buffalo Nickels (1913–1938)

Catalog

Group

Series

Category Icon

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

Grid View

List View

1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
9
1936 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
10
1937 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
6
1938-D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
3
1938-D/S 5c Buffalo, OMM, FS-511 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS68
2
eBay
eBay
Sponsored
1938-D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
5
1938-D/S 5c Buffalo, OMM, FS-511 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
5
CAC
1938-D 5c Buffalo MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS68
2
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/18/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
CAC
1928 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
6
CAC
1913-D 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
Sponsored
CAC
1937-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
CAC
1914 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
3
1916 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
1917 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
3
1923 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1925 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
3
Great Collections
Great Collections
Sponsored
1920 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1929 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
3
1919 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
1913 5c Buffalo, Type 2 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
4
1915 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
1919 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
6
Sponsored
CAC
1926 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1929-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
2
1913-D 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1929-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
1
1913-S 5c Buffalo, Type 1 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
3
1913-D 5c Buffalo, Type 2 MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
5
US Coins and Jewelry
US Coins and Jewelry
Sponsored
1916 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
NGC MS67
3
CAC
1935-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 8/31/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1929-D 5c MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1924 5c MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
CAC
1931-S 5c MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
1
1918 5c MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
3
David Lawrence Rare Coins
David Lawrence Rare Coins
Sponsored
CAC
1921 5c MS

Auction Ends: 9/2/2026

Seller - Heritage Auctions
PCGS MS67
4
1 2 ... 5