U.S. Coins for Sale/Bid

Greysheet Marketplace: Nickels, Shield Nickels Proof (1866–1883)

About the Greysheet Marketplace (Video)

Catalog

Group

Series

CAC

Grading Authority

Sale Format

Seller

Sort By

View:
1869 5c PCGS PR67
Charleston Rare Coins
Buy It Now
3,950.00
14
1870 5c PCGS PR65
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
525.00
28
1870 5c PCGS PR64
Grand Rapids Coins LLC
Buy It Now
679.88
15

Visit these great CDN Sponsors

CDN Sponsors

shop eBay
shop Stacks Bowers Auctions
shop Great Collections
shop CAC
shop David Lawrence Rare Coins
shop
cac.png
1871 5c PCGS PR64 CAC
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/8/2025
525.00
39
1871 5c PCGS PR63
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
360.00
29
cac.png
1872 5c NGC PR66 CAM CAC
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/8/2025
925.00
30
cac.png
1873 Closed 3 5c PCGS PR66 CAM CAC
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/8/2025
950.00
49
1874 5c PCGS PR67
DLRC
Buy It Now
3,006.25
199
1874 5c PCGS PR67 CAM
DLRC
Buy It Now
7,215.00
179
cac.png
1874 5c NGC PR66 CAM CAC
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/8/2025
1,050.00
56
1875 5c PCGS PR67
DLRC
Buy It Now
6,613.75
110
1875 5c NGC PR65
DLRC
Buy It Now
925.00
17
1875 5c PCGS PR64
DLRC
Buy It Now
601.25
59
1876 5c NGC PR67 CAM
Heritage Coin Wholesale
Buy It Now
3,000.00
3
Image
Coming
Soon
1877 5c PCGS PR66 CAM
Stacks Bowers
Auction Ends 12/9/2025
6
1878 5c PCGS PR64
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/9/2025
900.00
7
1879 5c NGC PR62
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/9/2025
250.00
7
1880 5c NGC PR66
Heritage Auctions
Auction Ends 12/15/2025
490.00
31

Visit these great CDN Sponsors

CDN Sponsors

shop eBay
shop Stacks Bowers Auctions
shop Great Collections
shop CAC
shop David Lawrence Rare Coins
shop
Previous 1 2 Next